O Captain! My Captain! - Which pirate did it better?

Killian Jones

Killian Jones from Once Upon a Time (ABC)

Jack Sparrow

Captain Jack Sparrow from The Pirates of the Caribbean (Walt Disney)

Dread Pirate Roberts

The Dread Pirate Roberts (aka Wesley) from The Princess Bride (20th Century Fox)

Image copyrights © ABC, Walt Disney, and 20th Century Fox, respectively. All rights reserved.